The Lookout by The Gardener's Cottage in Edinburgh
Where is The Lookout by The Gardener's Cottage?
🏠 38 Calton Hill, Edinburgh EH7 5AA
Elevated seasonal dishes served in a refined restaurant with floor-to-ceiling windows & city views.
Ver más Ver menos
Opinions
Minion A.
Loved this cute little place! 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟Not sure if reservations are required, but we got lucky, there was 1 table available for us when we arrived 👍🏻😀The menu is quite small, but I feel it is perfect for its simplicity, seems that most people should be able find something for themselves.We ordered mussels (2 identical plates), and they were hands down THE ABSOLUTE BEST mussels we've EVER had! They were buttery and soft (not chewy at all). If it wasn't our last day in Edinburgh, we would have come to eat there again for sure!One recommendation for the restaurant is to invest in an espresso machine, it would be so perfect after an amazing meal!5 stars 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
Voyager e.
5 stars for the venue, so gorgeous! And the people were very friendly. But it’s outrageous that the cheapest glass of wine is more than 10 pounds. And it wasn’t even nice, it tasted like cheap wine. It’s just a pity because the restaurant is awesome. The food was nice!
Mauro P.
The perfect location to enjoy delicious refined dishes with an outstanding view of the city. Amazing. Very good service too. We also had a nice chat with the waiter who went out of his way to make us feel at ease and gave us great suggestions on what to see and do in Edinburgh. Highly recommended
panyaphon p.
Small place but amazing view. Enjoy my lunch and food there.
Joshua M.
An absolutely brilliant dining experience.⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐A small venue; The Lookout offers an intimate dining experience, perched high above Edinburgh and overlooking the Firth of Forth. Incredible views, welcoming staff and fresh, seasonal produce denote this as a highly original and memorable experience.🍽️ We'd previously enjoyed an evening meal at The Gardener's Cottage - an essential visit for any foodie visiting Edinburgh - so the chance to try this sister venue is something that I immediately jumped at.🥐 We had breakfast here which was delicious and very well-curated. Items are shared as platters, split across two main servings (menu attached). All of the fold was beautifully presented, was incredibly fresh and provided a very balanced and enjoyable breakfast.A couple of bits of constructive feedback:- At breakfast, each diner has a single side plate which your supposed to eat all of the courses off of. This includes meat, cheese, pastries etc which is all fine, but also fresh fruit salad with the accompanying fruit juice. To my mind the fruit needs to be served individually in bowls. I requested a new plate and whilst the request was accommodated, I detected a hesitation to do so in case everyone asked for this. An easy improvement to make and one which is essential.- Coffee top-ups could be offered more readily. After the original small cup, we were only offered one additional refill. Similarly, we had to request additional orange juice as only one very small carafe was served for every four guests (it supplied approx.1/5 of a glass of juice per person.- Signage for the last few meters isn't very clear, especially considering that it's effectively a venue within a venueThe good news is that all of the above are very easy tweaks to make and would really help to elevate the perception of the overall experience.I would highly recommend a visit to The Lookout.
Steve H.
Just absolutely stunning.No real further comments needed, however the staff were great, friendly and obviously took passion in their work. The food was amazing, the portions were good with plenty of flavour and the views are just breathtaking over the city and forth!
kevin s.
The tasting menu was incredible. The wine was delicious and definitely value for money Our server was excellent, he guided us through the wine list easily and was welcoming and chatty. The view is incredible too! Amazing all round
nuric
What a great experience. We came for breakfast and really enjoyed it. Yes, the views are amazing and the cafe is designed to maximise your vantage point. They offer a fixed menu which I think works really well. Normally, cafes with views compromise on food quality because people come for the view but by giving a fixed menu, the standard was really good and tasty. The staff are friendly and professional. We are giving 4 stars because it wasn't allergy friendly. We were hoping there would be simple alternatives to pastry and bread that was nuts and sesame safe. Overall, an amazing cafe and I would definitely recommend you book and visit.
Katie B.
The food was quite disappointing and did not live up to the price point at all, or to the Gardeners Cottage namesake. I’ve been to Gardeners Cottage a few years ago and had fantastic food - the food at the Lookout is not even in the same league, and it feels like an insult to Gardeners Cottage to reference that in the name of this restaurant. When you’re eating here, it definitely feels like you’re paying for the view way more than the meal, which is never a good thing. I’d rate the food here a 2, but I’ve added one star for the view, service, and atmosphere.View: Obviously the best tables are the ones around the window edge. We got unlucky with a 6:00 booking to get stuck in the middle. Still a lovely view but not as nice. I’d recommend going for the first booking available to ensure a window seat, or to make a booking for around 7:30, as that seemed to be the changeover time.Food:- We were served a crab tartlet to start. It was reminiscent of a lobster roll but nowhere near as good. Should have been more buttery with less sourness.- Beef tartare was next. We were both excited for this one but in the end agreed it was the worst beef tartare either of us had ever had. The meat was not cut small enough and was strangely stringy. The topping was also all over the place, and it was way under seasoned. We were seriously shocked at the poorness of this dish.- The halibut was forgettable. The best part of the dish were the potatoes which were very delicious.- The duck was again one of the worst iterations of duck that I’ve had in a fine dining restaurant. It was stringy and the sides & sauce it was served with just didn’t really do much for it. By the time I was halfway through it started feeling like work to finish this dish, which is again not how you want to feel.- The dessert was easily the best course, which isn’t a great sign because it was one of the easier things to get right, being a pile of chocolate with hazelnut and raspberries. This was very tasty, but I’d expect more creativity at this price point.- They served truffles at the end which was a nice tough. They were fine, not great.Service wise: we had relatively quick and attentive service. All servers wear masks and the one we had spoke so quietly we couldn’t hear a thing she said. Sorry to say but the servers need to be speaking up to counteract the effects of the mask.All in all, we had a nice night here. The food wasn’t worth the price and the view didn’t quite make up for it, but it was still a nice experience overall. I’d say if you’re picking between places, there are much tastier options than this at a similar price point, like Gardeners Cottage, Timberyard, or Aizle. None of those have a view, but all provide a lovely experience and way better food, far more worthy of the spend.
Stefan I.
Everything was perfect!The place is just a small glass box with stunning views all around. We were placed in a table in the middle but honestly still got enough views, so I’m happy. Plus we were the first group for the evening to sit in a middle table, so they did offer us to move and we declined as it was a hassle.Food is a set menu that comes at £55 for dinner. I had seen a slightly lower price on the website, so I was a bit surprised, but it could have been for lunch. Regardless, it was honestly worth it. Everything was presented well and tasted amazing. And coming from London, honestly the prices are not even that bad.Staff were very nice and attentive - for example they would always refill our tap water as soon as it finishes, without us asking.
Leave a comment:
-
Yes, at The Lookout by The Gardener's Cottage you can make a reservation using Exploretock o Learn more.
-
If you have any questions, you can contact The Lookout by The Gardener's Cottage by calling 0131 378 7990.
-
In The Lookout by The Gardener's Cottage they specialise in seafood cuisine.
-
338 customers of The Lookout by The Gardener's Cottage have given it an average rating of 4,2.