The Secret Italian in Barnsley
Where is The Secret Italian?
🏠 McLintock Way, Barnsley S70 6BF
Opinions
Jimmy H.
Enjoyable family meal out, a very cosy (little) restaurant, friendly staff. Did feel a little underwhelmed by the main dish which was 2 chicken thighs, some potatoes and broccoli, feel like this is the main part of the menu that could be improved. Felt like it needed an accompaniment such as a sauce or something.
elaine c.
An amazing Italian food experience. The taste of every course was exceptional. There is a lot of food to eat so please go with an empty stomach, in fact the owner recommended we had a light lunch on the day and this was sensible advice. Great atmosphere and ambiance served by friendly and welcoming staff. Very good value for money and even offered a doggie bag for the delicious Tiramisu!
Mark S.
We had our table booked for months in advance and I can see why it's so popular. Great food with a lovely atmosphere. Well definitely be booking again.
Sarah H.
Really lovely home cooked food and friendly staff. Only thing is I wish they would explain to you how it works when you come in, wasn't really sure what I was getting as I'd not been here before. Well worth a visit though. Basically you get 5 courses which are preset and you won't know until the day. It's actually pretty cool and saves on food envy when you see someone picking something better than what you chose. 🤣
Ian L.
Went there last night. Managed to get a last minute table for two after a cancellation. Definitely out of the way and the place is tint. Fourteen covers. We were sat next to the door. It's unique. Never experienced dining like it. So small that you had to tak to other tables. But that was one of the joys. Got there just before seven. Normally takes about an hour to have a meal at other restraunts, maybe hour and a quarter.3 hours.We were eating just after seven and left at ten. Margaret, the owner, gave us a ten minute break. And did we need it it. The food was fresh, plentiful and very tasty. From the olives to start to the dessert to end. Set menu, which I was a little dubious about at first. But they had planned it perfectly. Took our own beer and wine, also a bonus. Margaret is obviously very proud of the place and so she should be. Continuous banter and information all night but not in your face. Really recommend this. Won't disclose the cost but would have paid more. Actually saw the food being cooked. Very good and welcoming place. It's a culinary experience. Get it booked when you can and wait.
Chris P.
Our first time here and what a gem of a restaurant, the Valentine's menu was delicious, 6 starters before the main meal and then the desserts. All the food had so many flavours, we were Absolutely stuffed.You won't be disappointed with this Italian.Margaret and Jana are so welcoming.Many thanks Chris & Allison.
Rob H.
Superb food probably the best I have had for years. The chef is fantastic all the flavours just flowed together. Great decor, spotlessly clean and great service. The fact that they are booked up for months speaks volumes. Thank you for a fantastic night. Update 2.3.22 new chef, second time we have had the pleasure of her cooking, fantastic,very different menu to last twice we have eaten at The Secret Italian. Can't wait to go again. Thank you very much.
andrew s.
Fantastic experience laughed from entering the restaurant to leaving. Margaret and Claudia are a great double act. The food was very nice and the portions large. I was too full but it tasted that good I couldn't leave any. Booked again before we left. Highly recommended
Stu T.
Thus place is fantastic.For £27.50 you get a set menu, which for us was anti-pasti consisting of bruscetta, meatballs, borloti beans, garlic mushrooms, Mozzarella and salami.Followed by two different spaghetti dishes, then chicken and roast potatoes and veg, and finally the most delicious tiramisu.Unfortunately I didn't manage to take too many photos, as the food was so amazing we were tucking in before we even thought to reach for the camera.The place is very small so the atmosphere is amazing, the owners are real characters and make the evening so entertaining that you don't realise just how much time you are there.Just got back in and already trying to book our next visit.
Chris H.
Wow. The best dining experience. The food is fantastic and Claudia/Margaret are amazing. We will definitely be booking back in. The only down side is that it is so long before we can go back.
Leave a comment:
-
If you have any questions, you can contact The Secret Italian by calling 01226 244888.
-
In The Secret Italian they specialise in italian cuisine.
-
141 customers of The Secret Italian have given it an average rating of 4,8.