Goodfellas Italian Restaurant in Rotherham

Went for a family birthday. Can I just say, this is without doubt the best Italian meal I've ever eaten. Simply delicious. Very friendly atmosphere. Pricy but worth every penny. Will definitely use again.

Just like to say this place is amazing, left a message today and within 30mins they rang us and booked us in for this evening. Food was so tasty and portions amazing, staff were great and so welcoming can’t wait to return.

Two stars for the friendly service but the Calzone was really poor. Undercooked dough containing a few mushrooms and a slice of ham. It was bad and we will not be returning

Been going now for a few weeks every thursday night with my wife. Food is amazing cooked to perfection. Very friendly staff and the owners go above and beyond to make you feel welcome. Enjoy having a chat with the owners everytime we go. Feels like home .Excellent

Just eaten at Goodfellas. Great pizza, chillied up a notch especially for me. Very generous with the topping, could barely eat it all! Highly recommended.

Absolutely amazing customer service and very very nice food.Will definitely be a regular visitor

This restaurant is the real deal - the montepulciano house red was gorgeous and the food cooked simply but to perfection. Marcello told me his wife made the Tiramisu which was to die for

Lovely visit to this Italian restaurant. Made even better for me as it was a nostalgic visit to my childhood home, and infact, was where I was born. Attentive staff. Great food. Couldn't manage a pudding and they sounded so good.

A great restaurant with great quality food. Service was excellent, the restaurant is relatively small but very well laid out, the atmosphere is very friendly (family run I think), we had a romantic meal but we plan to return for a birthday celebration in a few weeks. I cant recommend Goodfella's enough, we'll return again & again

We was seated straight away & given a warm welcome by all staff! Our drinks orders were taken quickly & we were given enough time to choose our food! The garlic bread starter was amazing! So fresh! I had linguine with meatballs & this wasn’t even on the menu but there was no issue with making me this at all & in all honesty it was the best pasta dish I have ever tasted! The sauce was amazing! My partner had a pizza & he said this was also amazing! The staff literally cannot do enough for you! They are all so lovely & friendly! This is now our favourite restaurant & will certainly be back very soon!!